Judge the Decision, Not Just the Outcome

Judge the Decision, Not Just the Outcome

October 25, 2026•2 min read

Judge the Decision, Not Just the Outcome

It's the end of the month, which makes this a natural time to look back. And if we're honest, most of us look back the same way: it went well, so we must have done it right. It didn't, so we must have gotten something wrong. That feels like a review. It's only half of one.

What Advanced Businesses Notice

Newer businesses review results. Did the campaign work? Did the sale close? Results are visible, so they get all the attention.

Businesses further along separate two questions: how did it turn out, and was it a sound decision given what we knew at the time? A well-reasoned decision can still land badly because of timing, luck, or something outside your control. And a sloppy decision can get rescued by a lucky week. If you only review outcomes, you'll repeat lucky mistakes and walk away from smart moves that happened to have a flat week.

Why This Happens

The concept here is outcome bias. Researchers Jonathan Baron and John Hershey documented it in the 1980s: people judge the quality of a decision by how it turned out, even when they have the same information the decision-maker had when they made the call.

Hindsight makes it worse. Once you know how it ended, the right answer looks obvious, and the thinking at the time looks careless or brilliant depending on the result. The fix is to write down your reasoning before the result arrives, so you can judge it fairly later.

Review the Decision

That's the Y in our FOXY Method™: Yield & Yearly Review. A review that only looks at results teaches you to chase luck. A review that looks at decisions teaches you to get better, and it gives your yearly review real material to work with.

This week's Sunday FOXY Focus email shows you how to do it, with a three-level action (Good, Better, Best) that meets you where you are, a reflection question, and a Fox Tip that makes next month's review honest.

Want help reviewing a decision you're second-guessing? Bring it to the Tuesday Strategy Spot.

Team Social Fox

Team Social Fox

Bonni J. Lee and Elizabeth Fiorentino Williams are the co-owners of Social Fox, bringing 50+ years of combined experience in marketing, technology, operations, and business growth. Together, they help small business owners build smarter systems to automate, connect, and grow.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog